HRC38: Joint Statement on the Need for Accountability Amidst Technical Cooperation
6 July 2018 10:53 am
38th Regular Session of the UN Human Rights Council
Item 2 and 10: General debate
Oral Statement Delivered by R. Iniyan Ilango
on behalf of Asian Forum for Human Rights and Development (FORUM-ASIA),
Cairo Institute for Human Rights Studies, Conectas Direitos Humanos, Freedom House, Human Rights House Foundation, Human Rights Watch, International Commission of Jurists, International Humanist and Ethical Union (IHEU), and International Service for Human Rights (ISHR)
Thursday, 05 July 2018
Thank you, Mr. President. While we appreciate the importance of technical cooperation, we wish to stress that a debate on technical cooperation will be incomplete if it does not address non-cooperation and country situations that have worsened despite technical cooperation. We are alarmed by efforts to restrict discussion on such situations by some states under Agenda Item 10, including for instance by (the Bolivarian Republic of) Venezuela earlier today.
While we recognise that all delegations including NGOs are required to speak on the topic under discussion, we are deeply concerned when NGOs making relevant statements are interrupted and not given a chance to explain the relevance of their statement, and in some cases are even prevented from finishing the statement. This has happened even when an NGO is speaking specifically on concerns addressed by UN reports listed for discussion in the relevant debate. Statements on Cambodia in the March session of the Council is a recent example.
The concept of international cooperation should never be invoked to shut down any criticism of human rights situations in individual countries. Cooperation cannot succeed without accountability. To be effective, debates on technical assistance and capacity building must be open to frank discussion of the true gravity, character and extent of on-going violations in the country in question, as well as the impact or lack of impact of any assistance already undertaken.
For a PDF version of this statement, click here.